the imaginative conservative logo

anglophileI became infected with this most deadly disease when I was ten years old. The 1966 World Book Encyclopedia Yearbook arrived, and working my way through it I came across the obituary of T.S. Eliot. There he was in his “five piece suit” gazing at the camera in that lugubriously quizzical way he had. I learned that he grew up in the United States but went to live in England and became a poet. For some odd reason I decided that I wanted to do that too.

This infection was dormant until, in high school, I was chosen to play Beverley Carlton—a “flamboyant English entertainer” in Kauffman and Hart’s The Man Who Came to Dinner. How well I remember putting on the dinner jacket, the patent leather shoes, the accent, and the affected air of Noel Coward. The disease of Anglophilia burgeoned into the full blown affliction in college. I majored in Speech and English at the fundamentalist fortress of Bob Jones University, and plunged myself into the works of all the great writers, but especially C.S. Lewis, J.R.R. Tolkien, and their friends.

One afternoon, surrounded by the braying of Baptists and the fulminations of fundamentalists, I pondered what sort of religion these English writers followed. What creed did Donne and Herbert, Traherne and Vaughan recite? What church did Jane Austen attend? Where did Wordsworth worship and Blake bow down? I did not have an inkling what religion Lewis, Sayers, Williams, and Eliot followed, but I knew they did not attend Mount Pisgah Four Square on Fire Primitive Baptist Church of God of the Third Degree.

These scribblers were, of course, Anglicans (except for the papist Tolkien who must have made a serious mistake). Soon after this stunning realization, an even more astounding reality came to my attention. There was a little church in Greenville called “The Holy Trinity Anglican Orthodox Church,” and we were allowed to go there. It had been founded by a well-to-do board member of the university who, weary of the Episcopal Church’s flirtation and then adultery with modernism, divorced himself from her and married another. That other was a little schism called the Anglican Orthodox Church established by Bishop James Parker Dees of Statesville, North Carolina.

Bitten by the Anglophile bug, I jumped in and joined the little stone church in the bad part of town. There we learned to light candles, sing good hymns, kneel down, and say beautiful prayers out of a book. It was there that I was baptized and confirmed, and there, on a balmy Southern Spring evening, that I heard clearly the call to be a priest. Some American boys want to be president, or an astronaut, play in the NFL, or make a million bucks. I wanted to be an Anglican country parson like George Herbert, live in a rambling rectory in a lovely village, write poems, and pray in a church older than Methuselah.

51rIqWzv2wLFor graduation a friend gave me a picture book which is still on my shelves, C.S. Lewis: Images of His World. It was a heady mixture of the mellow quads of Oxford and Cambridge, cozy fires in common rooms and pubs, the golden green countryside of England and the tweedy, bookish friends of Lewis. Quite drunk with the dream, I wrote a letter to J.I. Packer— the only Anglican theologian I had heard of, asking if he might recommend a seminary in England. He wrote a very kindly letter back suggesting two or three and, with typical American chutzpah I applied and was accepted to study theology at Wycliffe Hall in Oxford. Oxford! I was determined to first study, then live in the hallowed haunts of C.S. Lewis. T.S. Eliot and their literary coterie.

After three years I was ordained as an Anglican priest, spent four years in Sussex, two more in Cambridge as a chaplain at Kings’ College and finally became the vicar of Brading on the Isle of Wight. Lovely village? Check. Rambling rectory? Check. Writing poems? Check. Church as old as Methuselah? Check. Check. St Mary’s, Brading and St John the Baptist, Yaverland were both built in the eleventh century by the invading and enterprising Normans.

As providence would have it, I stepped out of the Anglican boat to walk on the waves with Peter. We entered into full communion with the Catholic Church, but leaving Anglicanism was not to leave England. We lived there as Catholics for another ten years before returning to the United States.

And leaving England was not to leave England, for part of England still lives within me. Now in this month of October there is a surging love for the Old Country—a kind of Autumnal homesickness for my adopted home. I miss the little lanes and seasoned countryside. I miss the sense of centuries infused into every stone of every ancient building. I miss the absurd apologies of the English, the pride they take in their failures, the irony of their wit, and their unerring sense of the ridiculous. I miss their little Englander arrogance, their silly snobbery, and their shabby elegance. I miss both their good taste and their vulgarity. I miss the sad foolishness of the Church of England, the pugilistic pomposity of their politics and the noble ordinariness of the Queen.

The universals abide in the particular, and what I miss about England is best expressed in this whole list from that fair and infuriating land:

Rievaulx Abbey

Rievaulx Abbey

Walking the South Downs Way with a black labrador. The Long Man of Wilmington. Visiting castles. Fawlty Towers. The North Cornwall Coastal path. Sausages. Mustard. Sticky Toffee Pudding. Custard. Flemish paintings in the National Gallery. Staying in farmhouse Bed and Breakfasts and eating lunch in country pubs. Watt and Co, Little St Mary’s, Cambridge. A pint of English bitter. Dad’s Army. Really good fish and chips. Rievaulx Abbey. St Laurence, Bradford-on-Avon, Choral Evensong at New College, Oxford. The upper reaches of the River Thames. WH Smith. Westminster Cathedral. Christmas Cake, crackers, pudding and carols. St Ethedreda’s Ely Place. Canals and canalboats. The Church of St Mary and St Alphege, Bath. Roast potatoes. Downside Abbey. those gas water heaters they have over their bathtubs that sound like engines on airplanes. Glastonbury. Tea with old ladies. Brown Sauce. Squash (the game, not the drink) Anglo-Catholic Churches. Medium Dry Sherry. The Isle of Wight. Lawn Tennis. Tintern Abbey. The Bird and Baby, the Perch and the Turf all in Oxford. St Mary Magdalene’s, Oxford. Old Libraries. Pusey House. Mesopotamia. North Oxford. Private Eye. Merton College, Those soldiers with bearskin hats and scarlet tunics. Yaverland. BBC Radio 4. The Belles of St Trinian’s. Denis Thatcher. Christmas pantos. King’s College, Cambridge. Stonehenge. Charity shops. The Daily Telegraph. Gin and Tonic. pre-1985 Anglican vicars, Strawberries and cream. Newman’s Rooms at the Birmingham Oratory. St Aloysius, Oxford. Croquet. Little Gidding. East Coker. Quarr Abbey.

Books on the topic of this essay may be found in The Imaginative Conservative Bookstore.

Print Friendly
"All comments are subject to moderation. We welcome the comments of those who disagree, but not those who are disagreeable."
9 replies to this post
  1. Fascinating article; as an Englishman I can only be pleased to know there are people who find our culture so irresistible as to make the effort to participate. I’m sad however that you’ve reverted subsequently to your roots!

    However I’m curious to know how you came to abandon the CofE that needs as many conservatives in its ranks. My father was an Evangelical back in the old days when we were marginalised almost to extinction; his strategy, and one that is widely adopted by those who cling on, is to remain within the ranks as gospel preaching parishes, ignoring the wider CofE’s latest fad, fanaticism or foible; because it remains a good place to fish from. If we are primarily concerned to bring the lost to God, then we need to make that a priority? By contrast Rome’s record in evangelism is appalling; its attendance in England would be crashing even more than it is if it wasn’t for the numerical injection offered by the renewed migration of Catholics to our shores. Similarly England’s encounters with the Imperial Papacy demonstrated in the events of King John’s reign, as well as the Spanish Armada (a crusade no less!) and the fall of James II, render its history overwhelmingly problematic to me. I find it interesting the defeat of both the Armada and James II were strongly enabled by weather events… Whilst of course there is much good in Catholic theology, overall its more recent history – papal infallibility and the resultant schismatic doctrines – make it inconceivable for me as a future home. By contrast the likes of Holy Trinity Brompton and St Helen’s Bishopsgate offer evidence of real life within the CofE – though for myself I’ve been forced out of my own parish by its endorsement of gay relationships; given that Rome’s pastoral practice, in at least some parishes, does no better, implies it has no real bragging rights on this issue.

  2. I have longed for England since I was a small child. I dream of quaint little villages, beautiful old churches, rolling moors, and English gardens. It has captured my heart, and it’s good to know I am not alone.

  3. Ender’s Shadow. Thank you for your comment. One’s conversion to Catholicism is both complex and simple. The complex is too much to explain in a comment box. The simple is that the Church of England’s decision to ordain women to the priesthood made me re-examine the authority structures in the C of E and they seemed to have no more foundation than any other Protestant sect. It was the ancient apostolic authority of Rome which became a rock on which to build. And then I realized that Jesus had intended it as such from the beginning…”You are Peter and on this Rock I will build my church.”

  4. Father Dwight, I fully understand and identify with much of your Anglophilia, your longing for England and your time there. I’m an American Roman Catholic who found himself living in Spain, but a member of an Anglican Church for many years there, for a number of reasons. We moved back earlier this year and while I’m perfectly at home in the Roman Church in the US, I find myself missing the traditional hymns and Holy Communion in traditional language. Even so, I just can’t bring myself to accept, much less buy into what most Episcopal churches have become in this country. That’s the real pity.

  5. Having stumbled upon and read Doyle’s ‘Holmes’ at the East Liverpool (Ohio) Carnegie Public Library by the age of fourteen I, too, became something of an ‘Anglophile’. Marrying a West Virginia Lit major who, dutifully read aloud Lewis’s ‘Narnia’ tales to two daughter and two grandchildren while providing me with a working knowledge of his more serious tomes, and filling her personal library shelves with the authors you’ve mentioned, has only compounded the illness. While my Irish-immigrant ancestors found ‘work’ in England they did depart in due course for America, finally settling in “Irishtown,” an ethnically mixed neighborhood that included the English and they seemed, at least from the stories I’ve heard, to cohabit rather cordially, oft intermarrying. Sadly, I did not matriculate to Oxford or Cambridge but I am a devotee of PBS’s Brit theatre, happily eschewing the narcissistic and moribund American TV. In the end, however, there’s a part of my psyche that turns to the Emerald Isle and the great clans of Scotland from whence came my mother’s people. So, it’s Harris tweeds, vests, and driver’s caps for my Sunday mornings with the Free Methodists whilst fondly recalling the inherent and profound mysteries of ancient liturgies, the selcouth effects of incense, and Latin recitations dutifully rendered in cassock and surplus at old St. Aloysius.

  6. Check on the World Book Yearbook.
    Check on The Man Who Came to Dinner (I was Whiteside).
    Check on Eliot.
    Also C. S. Lewis, Doyle, the Bald and Bawdy Bard of Avon, E. Philips Oppenheim, Christie, Sayers, Tey, and most of all, Kipling.
    “What do they know of England, who only England know?”

  7. Father Dwight – your Anglophilic list touched my heart. Have you been eavesdropping on my thoughts?! Not surprised to hear you left Anglicanism, which found its mind, but lost its soul. Roman Catholicism does indeed represent England as it was before the Reformation – now you only have to go back 500 more years to the time before the Conquest, when England was in full Communion with the Orthodox East (including the period between the Schism of 1054 and the Norman Invasion of 1066), and maintained Orthodox doctrine and practice full and complete. Those wonderful Saxon and Celtic saints, so fully Orthodox, such as St Cuthbert of Durham, with vestments from Constantinople – they really call all Anglophiles back to the true English Christian roots, before the execution of the Saxon priests who refused to swear loyalty to Rome. If you haven’t had a chance to read “The Fall of Orthodox England” by Vladimir Moss, you really must take the time.

  8. English literature brought me to a love of England early on, and that love has always stayed with me. I’m glad you got to live out your Anglophile dreams, Fr. Dwight! Thanks for this lovely article.

Leave a Reply