the imaginative conservative logo


149-IMG_4886I will admit, with only the slightest embarrassment, that the November elections depressed me mightily.

As early as mid summer, I promised myself not to get worked up about the current state of politics. One candidate seemed frightful, and the other dreadfully dull. Neither vice presidential candidate did much for me, either, though a lot of friends were rather excited about the one from Wisconsin. I like Wisconsin. Quite a bit. Whenever I even get near to the border, I drive over to supply myself with cheese curds and beer.

But, this guy seemed pretty weak to me. He had some good thoughts, but they seemed rather timid.

Going into the election, I was pretty convinced that the choice was between Tweedleevil and Tweedledumb.

Still, it would be nearly impossible for me not to have voted. So, I watched and muttered and watched some more and muttered some more, exploded once or twice online, and then went back to watching and muttering. Then, I showed up first in line for my ward, talked with a really interesting farmer for ten minutes, signed the requisite forms, and voted.

I feel much better now, though I’m far from happy with the results of the election. Frankly, though, I’m sure I’d be that much happier had Tweedledumb won. And, I’m fairly certain it would not have been good for liberty, dignity, or anything else that really matters.

Most happily, Ted Cruz will soon be seated in the Senate, and Justin Amash will be returning to the House. These two will lend their immense talents to Rand Paul. For these three, I am thankful. I will pray for them and support them in every way possible, for I believe them not only the three finest individuals in national politics, but I fervently hope they are a foreshadowing of the future. From everything I’ve seen and read, these three speak their minds, and they do so from a standpoint of honest conviction.


A few days ago, I had the good fortune to speak at a local Republican women luncheon. Not surprisingly, I had a wonderful time. In preparation for my talk, I pulled out three things as reminders of better days and better leaders: an “Ike” lapel pin, a Goldwater elephant pin, and the ticket stub from Ronald Reagan’s May 17, 1981, speech at the University of Notre Dame.

As I prepared for this talk, I decided to speak about things that matter–that is, things that matter yesterday, today, and tomorrow. In other words, I tried to convince my audience (and myself) that we decide on a Tuesday will probably not change the world on a Wednesday.

Instead, it struck me forcefully again (as it has many times in my life) that many of the things of this world are rather fleeting.

While I’m certainly not willing to give up the things of this world to the enemies of all that is humane and good, I’m also in a mood to recognize that we might very well have the opportunity to begin rebuilding the Republican party in the way Goldwater did in the early 1960s, preparing the way for Reagan in the 1980s.

Everything good takes time.

The Republican party since 1989 has proven itself little more than a “me too-ism” party. Every one, left and right, wants the charisma of Reagan, but no one really understands him or why he succeeded.

He succeeded because his ideas and convictions matched his charisma, making him even more attractive.

After years of Republican me too-ism, we finally have three men in the Republican party willing to stand as men, willing to oppose what’s wrong in the world, and willing to do so from the standpoint of conviction and honesty.


I must also admit, I find the notion of supporting a third party somewhat appealing. But, as I think every one is willing to agree, the two major parties have a lock on the American political structure. For those of us who read and love Winston Elliott’s TIC, we will find our only hope of any political success in the Republican party.

The Democrats are now fully the party of war, surveillance, and conformism. With only a few exceptions, the Republicans are just as bad.

In the late 1950s, a movement originating at the University of Notre Dame began to draft Barry Goldwater as a presidential candidate. That movement–a movement of a number of academics willing to lend their talents to Goldwater–ultimately led to the Arizonan’s victory in the 1964 Republican primaries. He called them constantly and relied upon them for a clarification of ideas as well as speeches.

In his many letters to Russell Kirk, the politician reminded the younger man again and again not to attack Democrats merely, but to support the conservatives. That is, Goldwater believed the conservatives could win only if they presented their ideas in an appealing manner, a manner that spoke of truth rather than opportunism. No victory could ever be expected by merely reacting to the opposition.

The actual election results of that November were a disaster for any American supporting individual liberties, but a small republic of letters had already formed, a movement had taken shape, and those same lovers of Goldwater saw in Reagan, as early as the mid 1960s, a proper successor to the conservative movement.

Over the entire history of the party, the Republicans have far more to be proud of than do the Democrats. From their beginnings, the Democrats have been the party of imperialism, racism, and abuse of the presidency. After all, this is the party that resegregated the military, deprived loyal Japanese-American citizens of their property and rights, and nuked two civilian cities in the second world war.

The Republicans began as a party desiring the prevention of slavery in the territories, and they have more consistently uphold civil liberties and the rights of the innocent than have the Democrats. The Republicans also helped end the Cold War.

The party desperately, though, needs to find its voice again, and that voice should not be found in the supporters of big military expansion, the national security state, massive corporations, or Washington think tanks.

The real voices of the will come from Texas, Kentucky, and western Michigan. If we aid them, they will bellow.

Books mentioned in this essay may be found in The Imaginative Conservative Bookstore


Print Friendly
"All comments are subject to moderation. We welcome the comments of those who disagree, but not those who are disagreeable."
7 replies to this post
  1. Sadly, the only thing that the Republican party appears to represent these days is lower taxes. Lower taxes are great when you aren't encumbered by a massive debt.

    The Republicans ARE the voice of big military expansion, the national security state, massive corporations, and Washington think tanks. I haven't heard any new ideas emerge from the Republican party (or the Democrat party) in years.

  2. Not all the think-tanks are bad, and every nation that desires to protect and ensure its sovereignty needs a strong military, for defensive purposes if nothing else. However, I do concur that the party has been co-opted by corporate statists and we still are going crazy about national security. Plainly ridiculous.
    The fact of the matter is that, unfortunately, there are NO NEW IDEAS in the political sphere anymore. At this point, the only choice we're getting is between soulless, laissez-faire capitalism which values money and the power it supposedly buys on the one hand, and quasi-socialist statism on the other. I'm of the opinion that we let distributism (aka Chesterbelloc) or Alexander Chayanov's agrarian community have its day in the sun, but I sincerely doubt either of that's gonna happen.
    The most pressing matter for conservatives right now is to strengthen the bonds between us and continue to spread our message of tradition, prosperity, virtue, and community. The rest, as they say, is in God's Hands.

  3. But there are lots of new ideas. Sadly many of them are from China. Recently I read about automated medical scanning booths set up in rural areas for villagers. One enters the booth, is scanned and diagnosed, and a reciept for appropriate medication is printed. All part of the Internet of Things project that the Chinese government is financing to the paltry tune of 800 million dollars, and which the private market is developing within a growing market. The amazing story is here:

    So, while President Obama spends trillions to build a Soviet healthcare system in the US, Chinese enterpreneurs pave the way for what will surely reduce and universalize basic healthcare at a high level from what will one day be family robot doctors.

    The sad thing is that articles like this were once about America. The world would read and marvel at what amazing things Americans were doing.

    One final example: people here in Warsaw, as they watched the recent Presidential debates were all asking me the same question: "why does Gov. Romney propose social security reforms identical to the ones Poland passed in the 1990s?" A system of private social security accounts (payment is sadly compulsory, but you choose what stock or investment portofolio your money goes to or whether to keep it with the State) has been in place in Poland for well over a decade. People here could not understand why the Americans were having this discussion in 2012, and why social security in America was identical to what it had been under communism in Poland. The assumption of most people here is that America surely has a better, more intelligently designed system.

    This assumption about American supremecy in political and technological innovation is rooted in the fact that it was true until not too long ago. Now, President Obama seems intent on making America "like Europe", but he didn't get the memo that the European welfare state of '68 lore is now the part of Europe mired in recession and depression, while the Europe of prudent market economy is relatively sound.

    Fittingly enough – you do all realize that the West as we know it is right now, just as it is collapsing, being led by self-annointed Saints? President Obama is a Nobel Laureate, and this year all of the Prime Ministers of the EU were invited to Oslo to collectively recieve a Nobel Prize for the EU.

    Is this not just perfectly Stalinist? All of our leaders have won Nobel Peace Prizes. Never in human history has all of the West been ruled by Nobel laureates. I think the historians of the future will enjoy writing this fact down as one of the symptoms of civilizational collapse

  4. "Lower taxes are great when you aren't encumbered by a massive debt". Lower taxes are a great idea precisely because of the debt. When there is prosperity, good things happen. Unfortunately, we get used to good times, think they will go on forever, and fall back asleep.

  5. My grandfather Jim Fuller, who was a lifelong Democrat, understood that Republicans would cut the throats of men who tried to protect themselves against the greedy businessmen who made farmers who were forced off the land by Republican laws work in incredibly bad conditions and blackball anyone who tired to form a union, was honorable more than any of the so-called freedom-loving members of the party of big business and wall street.

  6. "He was level on a level,
    shaved even every door.
    Grandpa voted for Eisenhower,
    'cause Lincoln won the war!"
    John Prine, of Muhlenburg County, Kentucky

  7. Nothing will change for the better in either party without the wholesale rejection of the philosophy of hedonism and narcissism (that is the hallmark of western society today) and a return to morality and self-control. I fear that the majority of folks in this country no longer care for anything except having their own chicken in the pot, and envying the chickens in their neighbors' pots. As a precinct committeeman in the Republican Party in Illinois, I see first hand the desolation of the Party. It is controlled by invertebrate country-club wannabe elected officials who practice nepotism and politics for personal gain. It is disheartening to see true moral and conservative principles eschewed by these infernal rascals who sell out themselves and the Party every day. I am not sanguine about the future of the Republican Party, nor am I hopeful about the future of this nation.

Leave a Reply