Four Myths about the Iranian Election

by Stephen Mastyhassan rouhani

Western reporting on Iran is an example of our fascinating but increasingly tenuous connection to reality. Overall, media coverage is now so ritualized, restricted by convention and laden with hidden assumptions that it increasingly resembles Japanese classical drama or Balinese shadow-puppetry. A century from now, when scholars sift through the ashes of our civilization, they’re in for lots of fun.

In brief, much of what’s reported as happening usually isn’t, what’s happening and is reported usually doesn’t matter much, and what is missed altogether would usually be helpful for us to know. The reason is partly ideological; by the time that reporters peer through the umpteen dusty lenses of our Progressive values, and impose them on other cultures and systems, we can’t see clearly enough to find the lavatory much less puzzle out how to run a vast empire. Let’s focus on the Iran. [Read more...]

The Hope of Glory, Catholic England, Dayspring: Poetic Selections from J. Matthew Boyleston

by J. Matthew Boylestonwild colt

For the Means of Grace and for the Hope of Glory

With the tuft of his hind hoof,
the wild colt lunges
for the long felt of his wet nose—

an impossible maneuver,
one act of feckless grace,
the taste of mulchy horse on my tongue. [Read more...]

Obama Administration Scandals and the Pursuit of Good Government

by Bruce Frohnenobama administration scandals

Some conservatives, and our libertarian friends in particular, have been rather enjoying hearing about recent Obama Administration scandals. I would not begrudge anyone a certain amount of perverse pleasure in the discomforts of an administration that has been seeking to undermine our culture, way of life, and economic freedom since day one. But I honestly do not think these scandals are good news for our nation, let alone that they should lead us to believe that we will see any political, economic, or cultural improvements in their aftermath. Here I am thinking in particular of Greg Gutfeld’s enjoyable post. Gutfeld argues that “The IRS scandal, if perceived correctly, spells the end of big government.” How so?  Because, according to Gutfeld, it exposes the IRS as an ideologically biased, arrogant bully. By extension, apparently, big government has been shown to depend on thuggish minions and to be serving its own ends, rather than those of the people. For Gutfeld, the true victory in the IRS scandal is that big government is exposed as the untrustworthy, selfish beast that it is. [Read more...]

Marion Montgomery: Prophet Philosopher

Marion Montgomery

Marion Montgomery

by Michael M. Jordan

The Prophetic Poet and the Spirit of the Age by Marion Montgomery (in three volumes): Why Flannery O’Connor Stayed Home (1981), Why Poe Drank Liquor (1983), Why Hawthorne Was Melancholy (1984)

Marion Montgomery’s trilogy is an ambitious, indeed audacious, assessment of the social, political, literary, religions, and philosophical temper of the Western world since the Renaissance. The work is ambitious in its scope, focusing primarily on three American fiction-writers but also treating, sometimes at length, Western figures from Hesiod to T. S. Eliot, with hundreds in between. The audacity lies both in the scope of the work and in Montgomery’s penetrating, confident judgment of the works and figures he discusses. [Read more...]

Rethinking the Foundations of Education: Stratford Caldecott

by Andrew SeeleyStratford Caldecott

Beauty in the Word: Rethinking the Foundations of Education by Stratford Caldecott. Angelico Press, 2012.

Stratford Caldecott’s Beauty in the Word is like no book in the genre of classical education that I have read to date. It is personal, reflective, profound, spiritual, psychological, learned, practical. I have hopes that it will fill a great need in my work with Catholic schools seeking to recover and develop our lost traditions, but it might be too rich and varied for most educators. Still, I recommend it to anyone who is serious about Christian education at any level and has time to think with a man of great heart who has read widely and reflected deeply. [Read more...]

Reflection and Choice or Accident and Force

by David Corbin and Matthew Parks

David Corbin and Matthew Parks

David Corbin and Matthew Parks

Two hundred twenty-six years ago this May, the Constitutional Convention was scheduled to open in Philadelphia. While it took eleven more days for a quorum of delegates to assemble, it took those delegates less than four months to answer the question that had brought them together: what can be done to make the Articles of Confederation “adequate to the exigencies of the Union”? Their answer: nothing. And so they proposed an entirely new frame of government, justifying this revolutionary act with an appeal to the document that justified the original American Revolution, the Declaration of Independence: “That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government….” [Read more...]

Dawson, Eliot, and the Word

power of language

Christopher Dawson

by Bradley J. Birzer

Continuing the theme of language and its importance to the human person, both individually and relationally (see previous essay), let us turn now to Christopher Dawson.

The English historian Christopher Dawson (1889-1970), another patron of The Imaginative Conservative, embraced a solidly Aristotelian view of the social world.  Aristotle had famously written in his Politics that man is by nature a social animal, meant to live in community. To leave community, a man must become either a beast or a god, but he can no longer remain human. A man may not live outside his cultural inheritance, Dawson wrote, paraphrasing Aristotle, without becoming an “idiot, living in a private world of formless feelings, but lower than the beasts.” Not even offering the Aristotelian alternative of becoming a God, Dawson further noted that culture is the means by which “men have learned from the past” through “the process of imitation, education and learning and to all that they hand on in like manner to their descendents and successors.” [Read more...]

Nothing But Glory Gained – Pickett’s Charge at Gettysburg

Pickett's Chargeby Robert C. Cheeks

Just before 3 o’clock on the morning of July 3, 1863, Robert E. Lee rose by starlight, ate a spartan breakfast with his staff, and mounted his famous gray horse, Traveller, for the ride up Seminary Ridge at Gettysburg. He went in search of his ‘Old War Horse,’ Lieutenant General James Longstreet, commander of I Corps, Army of Northern Virginia. After two days of fighting in the summer-lush Pennsylvania countryside, the largest battle of the Civil War still hung in the balance. With Longstreet’s help, Lee intended to tip the scales. [Read more...]

The Crisis of Fatherhood

Stratford Caldecott

Stratford Caldecott

by Stratford Caldecott

The Winter 2013 issue of Humanum, the freely available online journal of the Pope John Paul II Institute for Studies on Marriage and Family in Washington, DC (or rather the Institute’s Center for Pastoral and Cultural Research), is devoted to the crisis of fatherhood in our culture. It contains articles and book reviews devoted to the literature on this topic. (The following notes are based on the Editorial for the issue.)

The collapse of marriage in the developed world is happening faster than many believed possible. Civil marriages exceed religious ones, and both are in steep decline. In Italy, the heartland of Catholicism, where the largest religious institution on earth might be expected to have some influence, there are only 3.6 marriages a year for every thousand inhabitants, compared to 4.7 for the European Union as a whole—in the wealthy parts of Italy the numbers are even lower. Clearly most couples now do not get married. Single parents, especially single mothers, are commonplace. Given that it is hard enough for a stable, loving couple to bring up a child, or children, the difficulties faced by single parents are formidable. [Read more...]

Andrew Klavan’s “If We Survive”….A Political Morality Tale

Andrew Klavanby Robert M. Woods

Andrew Klavan has started writing young adult fiction and for a Christian publishing house. While this may be a bad move for some writers, Klavan has navigated the move very well. In truth, Klavan is a fine popular contemporary novelist. The extra benefit of this enjoyable read is that it may indeed have an additional application in light of our political and economic times. Klavan is interviewed by National Review online and speaks insightfully about moral reality and the universe.

The plot line is simple as it tells of four teens who become trapped in a Central American country as a communist revolution unfolds. There is a typical range of characters, including one of the teens who is sympathetic for the revolutionaries and has the opportunity to see behind the curtain and get a glimpse of what really motivates the revolutionaries he has read about, including some of their manifestos. One political lesson is that if it is a heavy handed government bent on controlling the people of a militant cause desiring to redistribute the wealth, freedom is oppressed. One young lady is a remarkable, but not overly idealized example of fearlessness and how she came to be that way is well told. Without giving away too much, by the end of the novel, everyone is changed. [Read more...]

Welcome to our new Senior Contributor: Stratford Caldecott

Stratford Caldecott

Stratford Caldecott

by Winston Elliott III

The Imaginative Conservative extends a warm welcome to our new Senior Contributor, Stratford Caldecott. Mr. Caldecott is the G.K Chesterton Research Fellow at St. Benet’s Hall, Oxford and the editor and co-director of the Oxford-based journal Second Spring. Mr. Caldecott is the author and editor of several books. His works include: Beauty for Truth’s SakeBeauty in the Word, All Things Made NewThe Power of the RingThe Seven Sacraments, and his latest work, The Radience of Being. He served as a senior editor at several publishing houses, including Routledge and HarperCollins, and he is an editor for the Catholic Truth Society in London, the U.K and Ireland edition of Magnificat, and the online journal of the Pontifical John Paul II Institute, the Humanum Review. Mr. Caldecott is also a member of the editorial boards for Communio, The Chesterton Review, and Oasis, an organization that seeks to foster understanding between Muslims and Christians. [Read more...]

Is American Theater Really Dead?

by Daniel McInerny 

american theater

Bank of America Theater

Anybody catch the Tony Awards on TV the other night?

I thought so.

Actually, I didn’t watch the whole thing either. And I don’t think we missed much. The spectacle was largely banal and the nominated plays and players, for all I knew them, could have come from the Kabuki Theater. Kinky Boots, a musical adaptation of a less-than-renowned 2005 film about a drag queen who comes to the rescue of a shoe factory, won the award for best musical, while Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike, a Christopher Durang comedy about three emotionally stunted siblings having a hard time growing up, won the award for best play. Among the other nominees were the usual revivals (Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Cinderella, and Pippin), and adaptations (The Trip to Bountiful, Matilda the Musical).  [Read more...]